Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Accounting for Presidential Leadership in the Americas

Sat, May 30, 12:00 to 1:45pm, TBA

Abstract

What is presidential leadership in the Americas? Until recently case selection offered two alternative paths. Study of the American presidency focused on greater scientific rigour, but was limited by its single case while Latin American presidentialism was dominated by normative concerns regarding the institution’s inherent deficiencies.

To address these limitations we apply Steven Skowronek’s influential concept of ‘political time’, which identifies the ‘success’ and ‘failure’ of individual presidents depending on the nature and level of their support base in the political system. The application of the model builds on Skowroneek’s single American case to provide a deeper analysis of presidential leadership and theory. In particular it finds that:

One, political time is more abrupt in Latin America than US. Whereas the latter’s institutions have persisted over two centuries, the former has been punctuated with the rise and fall of distinct political regimes and their support base.

Two, despite assumption that transformational/reconstructivist presidents have greatest freedom of action and transactional/managerial presidents do not, the difference is not so great; all presidents are somewhat constrained.

Three, in contrast to American presidents who generally represent one leadership type, Latin American cases show that individual presidents can occupy one or more types.

Four, Latin America presents distinct presidential types which do not exist in the US, specifically what we call ‘failed reconstructivist’ (i.e. those who establish but fail to benefit from new political regimes) and ‘transitional’ presidents (who may support or confront a regime).

Authors