Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Beyond the Pink Tide: Hegemony, Democratization and Post-neoliberal Transitions

Wed, May 27, 12:00 to 1:45pm, TBA

Abstract

Building on John Beverley’s argument that current criticism of the ongoing Left projects in Latin America –elaborated from subalternist, decolonial and posthegemony perspectives– is but academic ultra-leftism, I argue that the democratic/anti-neoliberal left turn constitutes an event that, as such, speaks to the centrality of a form of political struggle defined along Gramscian terms: that which postulates the importance of disputing the formation of consent within civil society, aggregating popular demands through both social and electoral mobilization, and building an inclusionary counterhegemonic bloc around mass organic parties that target the state. My method borrows from Badiou’s treatment of disruptive historical events as experimental settings for testing different versions of the communist hypothesis. Thus, I propose to read the left turn not (only) as an isolated event, but as an experiment among many others in which a singular political strategy can be tested and contrasted. After considering the relative failure of other recent episodes of popular uprising (e.g. the Egyptian Revolution), I contend that the pink tide, albeit pink and not red, is a relatively successful experiment. I illustrate this perspective with a three-case comparison. Two very different parties operating in very different national contexts, the Bolivian Movimiento al Socialismo and the Uruguayan Frente Amplio, prove successful at deploying a long-term counterhegemonic strategy. Chile is a negative case where the Left’s inability to build hegemony seriously compromised the chances of a conducive post-neoliberal transition. Issues of political strategy, as Marxist method indicates, can only be solved in practice, not in theory.

Author