Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Localizing Transitional Justice: contributions from the Colombian case

Mon, May 30, 12:45 to 2:15pm, TBA

Abstract

The article focuses on the theme of transitional justice (TJ) in Latin America, particularly with the aim to investigate the mismatch between global TJ discourses and Latin American historical experiences when dealing with its violent past. The main question is: how has the TJ paradigm been accepted, rejected, redefined or appropriated by different local actors? Besides: how can different local responses contribute to the development of the global TJ paradigm? The selected case study is the so-called “Colombian transition”, whose definition as a case of “transition” is still considerably controversial. Based on the Colombian case, I argue, firstly, that trying to classify Colombia as a case of transition, according to current theoretical definitions of the field, is more misleading than enlightening, especially due to the lack of conceptual clarity in TJ writings. Furthermore, the close and blurred interconnection between academic analysis and activism tends to favor political misuse of TJ discourses and practices. Secondly, I analyze when, to whom and for what purposes the TJ discourse has been used or abused in Colombia, stressing the argument that, currently, TJ almost always applies to non-Western, developing countries and that its predominant view constructs human rights violation fairly narrowly. Finally, I try to observe local interpretations of traditional concepts of transition and to explore the idea of a regional, Latin American perspective on TJ. This study is particularly relevant since it broadens the focus of the global TJ paradigm by emphasizing local and regional entrepreneurship in reformulating universal legal and theoretical categories.

Author