Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Las Casas’ Articulation of the Indians’ Moral Agency: Looking Back at Las Casas Through Fichte

Mon, May 30, 12:45 to 2:15pm, TBA

Abstract

Much has been written on Bartolomé de Las Casas’ contribution to the notion of universal human rights. Liberation theology thinkers have thought of him as the central spokesperson and defender of the Amerindians, and as a voice that continues to speak for the oppressed and marginalized indigenous peoples of Latin America. For someone like Dussel, for instance, Las Casas represents the embodiment of proto-Marxian Christian ethics. What seems understudied is Las Casas’s conception of Christianity and generally, religion—a view of religion, which in some interesting ways coincides with an eighteenth century German enlightenment concept of religion, or what Kant called “the religion of reason” in Religion Within the Boundaries of Mere Reason. Interestingly, for the Spanish philosopher, Christianity, much more than faith, was a rational system of ethics, and as such, one that could be communicated through logical arguments and through the right kinds of actions so that others would want to follow it. Obviously, in order to believe that conversion to Christianity could be achieved this way, it was necessary to believe in the rational capacity of the target subject—in our case, the Indians. And this is precisely what makes Las Casas unique, even today—that is to say, that he believed that the Indians were rational, because they were civilized human beings with their own organized city states, in many ways more advanced than even that of the highest of Western societies, like those of the Greeks and the Romans. For Las Casas, the Indians were members of the same community of rational human beings articulated more than three hundred years later by Johann Fichte, which is why Fichte will serve us here—i.e., to shed some light on Las Casas anticipatory notion of moral agency, formal freedom, rational religion, and the rights of free people against the use of coercion—regardless of their race, their ethnicity, their nationality, or their culture. This, I believe, is what underpins, Las Casas’ notion of universal human rights, and his of ethics of the Other, who is just like me—a rational, feeling human being, deserving of equal justice and rights.

Author